The longest model in our lineup, this double-headed muddler stood tall in vessels of all sizes. With a moderate weight and a large, smooth head, this model quickly and efficiently muddled everything under it, making great drinks. Testers liked that it also had a second, smaller head, which was handy for maneuvering in narrow vessels or for making a second drink without having to wash the muddler. Made of unvarnished wood with indentations cut into it, this model was particularly easy to grip, even when wet. And although the wood stained slightly after its overnight cocktail bath, the muddler was otherwise quite durable.
Model Number: MUDDLER1Length: 11 inWeight: 6.63 ozMaterial: MapleHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Heads: 1.75 in, 1.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.95
The longest model in our lineup, this double-headed muddler stood tall in vessels of all sizes. With a moderate weight and a large, smooth head, this model quickly and efficiently muddled everything under it, making great drinks. Testers liked that it also had a second, smaller head, which was handy for maneuvering in narrow vessels or for making a second drink without having to wash the muddler. Made of unvarnished wood with indentations cut into it, this model was particularly easy to grip, even when wet. And although the wood stained slightly after its overnight cocktail bath, the muddler was otherwise quite durable.
Model Number: MUDDLER1Length: 11 inWeight: 6.63 ozMaterial: MapleHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Heads: 1.75 in, 1.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.95
Shop smarter with our ATK Reviews team's expert guides and recommendations.
What You Need to Know
A muddler is an important tool for any home bar; it’s primarily used to crush fruit and herbs so they express their essential oils and/or juices for use in cocktails. We wanted to know which muddler was best for home bartenders, so we ordered seven widely available options, priced from about $4 to about $18, and used them to muddle lime wedges, mint, and sugar cubes in a variety of vessels and to make mojitos.
All the muddlers were capable of making decent drinks, but a few factors made certain models more durable, easier to use, and better performers overall.
Dimensions Matter
The first factor? Length. Most of the time, we muddle directly in a cocktail shaker so that we can add and mix the rest of the drink ingredients afterward. Because the mixing cups of most cocktail shakers, including our winner, are 6 or 7 inches tall, we preferred muddlers that were at least 9.5 inches long. The longer the model, the taller it stood in the shaker, giving us more to hold on to when we pounded limes and mint. Shorter models worked well enough when we muddled sugar cubes in a squat old-fashioned glass but left only a stubby inch or so to grab when we used them with the shakers.
For similar reasons, we also liked muddlers that had discrete handles, or at least a bit of a taper or indentation between the muddling end and the end meant to be held. With no indentations, cylindrical models were a bit harder to grasp for longer periods since they didn’t provide a natural resting place for our hands. We also preferred models made from materials that were easier to grip, such as unvarnished wood or bamboo, or that had rubbery plastic overlays on their handles; smooth plastic models were a little too slick to hold on to, especially when they got splashed with drink ingredients.
We found that we liked muddlers with heads that were at least 1.5 inches in diameter. Models with smaller heads couldn’t cover as much territory as quickly, taking slightly more time to get all the juice out of the limes. And we preferred models with a little weight to them; 5 to 6 ounces was ideal, allowing gravity to do some of the work for us without becoming tiresome to use. Lighter models required us to use a bit more force; the one heavier model, weighing nearly a pound, fatigued our arms and felt cumbersome and a little dangerous when used in the old-fashioned glass.
How to Use a Muddler
Add your citrus and/or herbs to the vessel in which you want to muddle—usually this is the cocktail shaker itself, but in some cases (such as when making a caipirinha or an old-fashioned), this can be the glassware in which you intend to serve the drink.
Grip the muddler securely and then press firmly into the citrus and/or herbs, rotating the handle slightly as you do, until all the juice has been expressed from the fruit or until the herbs are fragrant. This can take between 20 and 30 seconds, depending on the muddler you’re using and the freshness of your ingredients.
Textured Heads Make Slightly More Fragrant Drinks
The style of the head itself made a small difference in the flavor of a finished drink. Some professional bartenders claim that muddlers with textured heads—heads covered with a nubbly grid or bumps—make bitter or muddy-tasting drinks because they dig too deeply into citrus pith and tear up herbs, promoting undesirable chemical reactions. We did not find this to be the case: While the textured muddlers shredded the herbs and abraded the citrus peel more than smooth muddlers did, the drinks made with these more aggressively muddled ingredients were still perfectly acceptable. Some tasters even preferred drinks made by textured muddlers, since their grinding action may have helped extract more oils and flavor compounds from the ingredients, resulting in somewhat more fragrant, complex drinks than those made by the smooth muddlers. Still, you can’t go wrong with either style of head; both types made good drinks.
Don’t Get A Lacquered Muddler
Finally, we considered the durability of the muddlers. We left all the models in a mixture of gin, water, and lime juice overnight, as if we’d forgotten them after mixing a cocktail; we then washed the models by hand or in the dishwasher 10 times, according to manufacturers’ instructions. After the overnight cocktail bath, we found that the lacquer coating on two of the wooden models had eroded slightly, seemingly dissolving into the liquid. While at least one of the manufacturers claims that this lacquer is food-safe, we’d prefer to limit our drink ingredients to the ones in our recipes. Muddlers made from metal, plastic, or unvarnished wood avoided this problem. Unvarnished wood can warp or crack if it’s not dried properly, and one wood model stained lightly after its cocktail bath, but overall, we prefer this material to plastic for its grippier texture.
While both lacquered wood muddlers had coatings that eroded in an overnight cocktail bath, this particular muddler—supposedly dishwasher-safe—eroded entirely after 10 washes.
The Best Muddler: Fletcher’s Mill Maple Muddler
Our winning muddler is Fletcher’s Mill Maple Muddler. At 11 inches long, it was the biggest muddler we tested, standing tall in every vessel. It had a moderate weight, and its slightly indented, unvarnished wood body was especially easy to grip. Testers particularly liked that it was double-ended, with one large smooth head and one slightly smaller one, allowing them to make different drinks with either end or to muddle in both small and large vessels.
Muddle limes
Muddle mint leaves
Muddle sugar cubes with bitters
Make mojitos
Leave in mixture of gin, water, and lime juice overnight
Wash 10 times by hand or in dishwasher
Tall enough to stand high in a cocktail shaker for easy grasping
Moderate weight for ease of use without fatigue
Large head that covers more ingredients more quickly
Easy to hold; made from grippy material, has indentations for your hands
The longest model in our lineup, this double-headed muddler stood tall in vessels of all sizes. With a moderate weight and a large, smooth head, this model quickly and efficiently muddled everything under it, making great drinks. Testers liked that it also had a second, smaller head, which was handy for maneuvering in narrow vessels or for making a second drink without having to wash the muddler. Made of unvarnished wood with indentations cut into it, this model was particularly easy to grip, even when wet. And although the wood stained slightly after its overnight cocktail bath, the muddler was otherwise quite durable.
Model Number: MUDDLER1Length: 11 inWeight: 6.63 ozMaterial: MapleHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Heads: 1.75 in, 1.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.95
The longest model in our lineup, this double-headed muddler stood tall in vessels of all sizes. With a moderate weight and a large, smooth head, this model quickly and efficiently muddled everything under it, making great drinks. Testers liked that it also had a second, smaller head, which was handy for maneuvering in narrow vessels or for making a second drink without having to wash the muddler. Made of unvarnished wood with indentations cut into it, this model was particularly easy to grip, even when wet. And although the wood stained slightly after its overnight cocktail bath, the muddler was otherwise quite durable.
Model Number: MUDDLER1Length: 11 inWeight: 6.63 ozMaterial: MapleHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Heads: 1.75 in, 1.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.95
With a large, textured plastic head, this muddler performed quite well. Some tasters preferred drinks made with this model because its nubbly surface massaged the citrus and tore through herbs, releasing flavorful oils and juices slightly more extensively than did muddlers with smooth heads. Its rubbery handle was particularly easy to grip, and it survived testing without any staining or other issues. It was just a tiny bit shorter and lighter than we preferred, making it trickier to maneuver in tall cocktail shakers and requiring us to work a little harder to pound ingredients.
Model Number: 3104900Length: 9 inWeight: 3.88 ozMaterials: Stainless steel, nylon, polypropylene, TPE, siliconeHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $13.95
With a large, textured plastic head, this muddler performed quite well. Some tasters preferred drinks made with this model because its nubbly surface massaged the citrus and tore through herbs, releasing flavorful oils and juices slightly more extensively than did muddlers with smooth heads. Its rubbery handle was particularly easy to grip, and it survived testing without any staining or other issues. It was just a tiny bit shorter and lighter than we preferred, making it trickier to maneuver in tall cocktail shakers and requiring us to work a little harder to pound ingredients.
Model Number: 3104900Length: 9 inWeight: 3.88 ozMaterials: Stainless steel, nylon, polypropylene, TPE, siliconeHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $13.95
This cylindrical plastic muddler was large and in charge, standing tall in every vessel we used; its large, smooth head allowed it to muddle all ingredients quickly and efficiently. It suffered no damage during testing. But testers found it heavy, and even with tiny grooves etched into its plastic surface, it was a little slippery when wet, especially since there were no indentations for our hands to grip.
Model Number: OTH-MUD-BASSLength: 9.6 inWeight: 14 ozMaterial: PlasticHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.5 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.99
This cylindrical plastic muddler was large and in charge, standing tall in every vessel we used; its large, smooth head allowed it to muddle all ingredients quickly and efficiently. It suffered no damage during testing. But testers found it heavy, and even with tiny grooves etched into its plastic surface, it was a little slippery when wet, especially since there were no indentations for our hands to grip.
Model Number: OTH-MUD-BASSLength: 9.6 inWeight: 14 ozMaterial: PlasticHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.5 inPrice at Time of Testing: $12.99
Durability
Ease of Use
Performance
The Modern Mixologist Bar Tools Solid Cherry Wooden Muddler
Shaped like a pestle, this tall wooden muddler was easy to maneuver in vessels of all sizes. A large, smooth head and a moderate weight meant that this model muddled every ingredient we gave it quickly and efficiently, and its tapered neck was comfortable to grip. But with a smooth lacquer finish, it was a little slippery when wet; that lacquer also eroded slightly when we left it in a cocktail solution overnight.
Model Number: MM-18001Length: 9.88 inWeight: 5.25 ozMaterials: Wood, food-grade lacquerHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.8 inPrice at Time of Testing: $18.00
Shaped like a pestle, this tall wooden muddler was easy to maneuver in vessels of all sizes. A large, smooth head and a moderate weight meant that this model muddled every ingredient we gave it quickly and efficiently, and its tapered neck was comfortable to grip. But with a smooth lacquer finish, it was a little slippery when wet; that lacquer also eroded slightly when we left it in a cocktail solution overnight.
Model Number: MM-18001Length: 9.88 inWeight: 5.25 ozMaterials: Wood, food-grade lacquerHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.8 inPrice at Time of Testing: $18.00
This bamboo muddler made good, fragrant drinks but took a little longer to do so, due to a relatively small textured head. It was easy to grip and was durable, holding up well after its cocktail bath and 10 washes. But it was a bit too short, with just an inch or two sticking up out of taller cocktail shakers for us to grab. It was also too light, making us work a little harder to pound ingredients.
Model Number: 51000Length: 8.4 inWeight: 2.5 ozMaterial: BambooHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1.3 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.99
This bamboo muddler made good, fragrant drinks but took a little longer to do so, due to a relatively small textured head. It was easy to grip and was durable, holding up well after its cocktail bath and 10 washes. But it was a bit too short, with just an inch or two sticking up out of taller cocktail shakers for us to grab. It was also too light, making us work a little harder to pound ingredients.
Model Number: 51000Length: 8.4 inWeight: 2.5 ozMaterial: BambooHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1.3 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.99
This plastic muddler was durable, and it got the job done. But with the smallest head of any muddler in the lineup, it took a relatively long time to muddle all the ingredients. And while its slimmer, shorter profile made it great for muddling in a stubby old-fashioned glass, it barely peeked over the rim of larger pint glasses and cocktail shakers, so it was hard to grasp. It was also lightweight, requiring us to use more force to muddle, and its cylindrical plastic body was slippery and hard to get a grip on, especially when wet.
Model Number: PBM-8NLength: 8.25 inWeight: 4 ozMaterial: PolycarbonateHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1 inPrice at Time of Testing: $5.48
This plastic muddler was durable, and it got the job done. But with the smallest head of any muddler in the lineup, it took a relatively long time to muddle all the ingredients. And while its slimmer, shorter profile made it great for muddling in a stubby old-fashioned glass, it barely peeked over the rim of larger pint glasses and cocktail shakers, so it was hard to grasp. It was also lightweight, requiring us to use more force to muddle, and its cylindrical plastic body was slippery and hard to get a grip on, especially when wet.
Model Number: PBM-8NLength: 8.25 inWeight: 4 ozMaterial: PolycarbonateHead Style: TexturedDiameter of Head: 1 inPrice at Time of Testing: $5.48
Not Recommended
Durability
Ease of Use
Performance
Winco Wooden 8″ Flat Head Muddler
This muddler was too short to grab on to when we used it with pint glasses and cocktail shakers. It was also too light, making us work harder to pound ingredients, and it had a head that was too small, taking a long time to handle all the ingredients. Worst of all, its lacquer coating eroded when we left it in a cocktail solution overnight, and more extensively in subsequent washes, making us worry that some of that coating might have made its way into every drink we made.
Model Number: WMW-8Length: 8 inWeight: 2.25 ozMaterial: Lacquered rubberwoodHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.1 inPrice at Time of Testing: $4.69
Durability
Ease of Use
Performance
This muddler was too short to grab on to when we used it with pint glasses and cocktail shakers. It was also too light, making us work harder to pound ingredients, and it had a head that was too small, taking a long time to handle all the ingredients. Worst of all, its lacquer coating eroded when we left it in a cocktail solution overnight, and more extensively in subsequent washes, making us worry that some of that coating might have made its way into every drink we made.
Model Number: WMW-8Length: 8 inWeight: 2.25 ozMaterial: Lacquered rubberwoodHead Style: SmoothDiameter of Head: 1.1 inPrice at Time of Testing: $4.69
*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.
Reviews You Can Trust
The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!
Miye is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. She covers bread, booze, and blades.
Miye Bromberg is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. Areas of specialization include bread, booze, and blades. A native of New York, she now lives in Kentucky, where she spends her free time thinking about film, tending her garden, and traveling long distances to eat dosas.