America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

Hawthorne Strainers

A strainer is an essential part of your cocktail kit. Which model is the finest?

Top Pick

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

WinnerCocktail Kingdom Koriko Hawthorne Strainer

With closely spaced, moderately tense coils, this strainer filtered out all but the fewest, tiniest bits of lime pulp, mint, and ice. Long wings allowed it to sit securely on the small and large halves of the shaker, and a tab on the head made it easy to grip while pouring.

Model Number: STR-KOR-STL

Handle length: 3.3 in

Distance between coils: 0.5 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $15.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

With closely spaced, moderately tense coils, this strainer filtered out all but the fewest, tiniest bits of lime pulp, mint, and ice. Long wings allowed it to sit securely on the small and large halves of the shaker, and a tab on the head made it easy to grip while pouring.

Model Number: STR-KOR-STL

Handle length: 3.3 in

Distance between coils: 0.5 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $15.99

What You Need to Know

If you use a Boston shaker to make cocktails, you’ll need a separate cocktail strainer to hold back the ice, stray herbs, and citrus wedges as you pour your drink into a glass. There are a few types of cocktail strainers, but the Hawthorne strainer is the most commonly used. It’s essentially a slotted and/or perforated disk with a spring mounted on part of the perimeter; the spring acts as a filter as liquid exits the shaker. We wanted to know which Hawthorne strainer was best for home bartenders, so we bought six models, priced from about $4 to about $16, and used them to strain ice and other typical cocktail ingredients.

Head Design Is Critical To Fit

All of the strainers will keep large ice cubes from plopping into your drink as you pour it into the glass—the bare minimum required of any cocktail strainer. But a few factors made certain models easier to use and capable of straining more finely than others.

Associate Editor Miye Bromberg evaluates the performance of a Hawthorne strainer.

Cocktail shakers vary in size, so the design of the head was critical in determining how well the strainers fit on different vessels. When using a strainer, the spring goes inside the shaker and metal wings or prongs attached to the head usually keep the whole thing perched on top. Not surprisingly, we preferred models that had wings or prongs that were long enough to reach the edges of larger shakers with room to spare, ensuring that they sat securely. One of the models had prongs that didn’t quite extend to the edges of the larger half of our favorite Boston shaker, requiring us to fuss with it to get it to latch on; as a result, the whole strainer sometimes fell into the shaker.

Handles And Finger Grips Matter, Too

Two other features determined how easy the strainers were to use. We preferred models that were well balanced, with relatively short, lightweight handles, 3.5 inches or shorter. One strainer had an unusually heavy, 5-inch-long handle that upset the balance of the whole unit, making it impossible to leave the strainer on top of the shaker without holding it in place, as it would flip backwards and fall off.

We also preferred models that had finger rests—little tabs sticking out from the middle of their heads—as these allowed for a more secure grip and better control over the strainer. You simply lay your index finger on the tab and press against the head to keep the strainer held tightly against the mouth of the shaker. By pressing down on the tab, you can also compress the spring and narrow the opening through which your drink strains, allowing you to filter the drink more finely as well.

Spring Design Determines Performance

Ultimately, how finely each strainer filtered out citrus pulp, bits of muddled mint, or ice chips was the most important factor. No strainer was able to prevent all debris from passing through its spring; if you want a drink that’s completely free of ice and pulp and herbs, you’ll need to filter your drinks through both a Hawthorne strainer and a fine-mesh tea strainer, as many bartenders do. That said, most of the strainers in our lineup did a fair job of holding back unwanted material. Realistically, we didn’t mind a few stray ice chips or tiny particles of mint, though we did prefer the models that strained more finely to those that let a bit more through.

Strainers with more closely spaced coils (right) did a better job of filtering out ice and herbs such as the mint in these cocktails.

What made certain models strain better than others? First and most important, the closeness of the coils on the spring. Strainers with gaps of less than a millimeter between their coils filtered drinks very finely, allowing almost no ice, mint, or lime bits through. By contrast, strainers with gaps of 1.3 to 2 millimeters left shards of ice covering nearly a third of the surface of the martinis they strained and permitted slightly larger shreds of lime pulp and mint to pass through. Because they catch more debris than loosely coiled springs, closely coiled springs can be more challenging to clean, but we think the performance advantages outweigh any minor annoyances in cleanup.

The tension of the spring also played a role in determining how easy it was to use the strainers. We found this action much more pleasant to perform with springs that had a moderate level of tension, as they were easier to push down than springs that were stiff and tightly coiled, but not as bouncy and hard to control as springs that were loose.

The Best Hawthorne Strainer: The Cocktail Kingdom Koriko Hawthorne Strainer

Our favorite strainer is Cocktail Kingdom’s Koriko Hawthorne Strainer. With a closely coiled spring pitched at a moderate tension, it did the best job of straining. Because it had a very large set of wings, it fit securely on vessels of different sizes; a finger tab made it easy to keep our grip on the strainer and adjust how finely we poured. Finally, it had a relatively small handle that helped keep the whole unit well-balanced.

  • Wide wings or prongs that reach the edges of both large and small shakers
  • Short handle
  • Finger tab for better grip and easier adjustment of pouring opening
  • Closely spaced coils with moderate tension

  • Muddle lime quarters, add water, and strain
  • Muddle mint leaves, add water, and strain
  • Make martinis and strain
  • Have users of different hand sizes, dominant hands, and levels of bartending experience evaluate each model
  • Wash 10 times in dishwasher

Everything We Tested

Good 3 Stars out of 3.
Fair 2 Stars out of 3.
Poor 1 Star out of 3.

Highly Recommended

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

WinnerCocktail Kingdom Koriko Hawthorne Strainer

With closely spaced, moderately tense coils, this strainer filtered out all but the fewest, tiniest bits of lime pulp, mint, and ice. Long wings allowed it to sit securely on the small and large halves of the shaker, and a tab on the head made it easy to grip while pouring.

Model Number: STR-KOR-STL

Handle length: 3.3 in

Distance between coils: 0.5 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $15.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

With closely spaced, moderately tense coils, this strainer filtered out all but the fewest, tiniest bits of lime pulp, mint, and ice. Long wings allowed it to sit securely on the small and large halves of the shaker, and a tab on the head made it easy to grip while pouring.

Model Number: STR-KOR-STL

Handle length: 3.3 in

Distance between coils: 0.5 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $15.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

HIC Cocktail Strainer

This strainer was nearly identical to our winner, with relatively long wings that ensured a good fit on both shaker halves and very closely spaced coils that strained well. The main difference: Its coils were a little stiffer, so it was a tiny bit harder to press the strainer against the shaker and adjust the opening through which the drink exited.

Model Number: 48027

Handle length: 2.5 in

Distance between coils: 0.4 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $9.15

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

This strainer was nearly identical to our winner, with relatively long wings that ensured a good fit on both shaker halves and very closely spaced coils that strained well. The main difference: Its coils were a little stiffer, so it was a tiny bit harder to press the strainer against the shaker and adjust the opening through which the drink exited.

Model Number: 48027

Handle length: 2.5 in

Distance between coils: 0.4 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $9.15

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

The Modern Mixologist Hawthorne Strainer

With a spring that was significantly larger than its head, this strainer had to be wedged into the shaker, an unusual maneuver that took a little longer to perform and initially gave some testers pause. Once in, however, it won those testers over because it fit so tightly into both halves of the shaker that it couldn’t possibly fall out during use. Its coils had good tension and were spaced fairly closely, making for a fine strain. And a small tab on the head helped us get a good grip on it.

Model Number: Hawstrain16001

Handle length: 2.6 in

Distance between coils: 0.8 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $16.00

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

With a spring that was significantly larger than its head, this strainer had to be wedged into the shaker, an unusual maneuver that took a little longer to perform and initially gave some testers pause. Once in, however, it won those testers over because it fit so tightly into both halves of the shaker that it couldn’t possibly fall out during use. Its coils had good tension and were spaced fairly closely, making for a fine strain. And a small tab on the head helped us get a good grip on it.

Model Number: Hawstrain16001

Handle length: 2.6 in

Distance between coils: 0.8 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $16.00

Recommended

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

OXO Steel Cocktail Strainer

With virtually no handle at all, this strainer was especially compact and easy to maneuver; small, well-placed prongs helped it sit securely on shakers of different sizes. Testers loved the rubbery tab on its head, which helped them keep a good grip on the strainer even when it was wet. But because its coils were spaced somewhat farther apart than we’d prefer, it allowed more lime pulp, mint, and ice shards to filter through—though it still did a decent job overall.

Model Number: 1058016

Handle length: 1.25 in

Distance between coils: 2 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $6.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

With virtually no handle at all, this strainer was especially compact and easy to maneuver; small, well-placed prongs helped it sit securely on shakers of different sizes. Testers loved the rubbery tab on its head, which helped them keep a good grip on the strainer even when it was wet. But because its coils were spaced somewhat farther apart than we’d prefer, it allowed more lime pulp, mint, and ice shards to filter through—though it still did a decent job overall.

Model Number: 1058016

Handle length: 1.25 in

Distance between coils: 2 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $6.99

Not Recommended

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

Winco 4-Prong Stainless Steel Bar Strainer

This inexpensive strainer did a fair job of straining lime pulp, mint, and shards of ice, though because its coils weren’t as narrowly spaced as our winner’s, it wasn’t quite as effective. The coils themselves were a little loose, making the strainer bouncy and harder to control during use. Worse, its top prongs were too short to reach the edges of our larger shaker tin, so it occasionally fell into the shaker while pouring.

Model Number: BST-4P

Handle length: 2.5 in

Distance between coils: 1.3 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $3.98

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

This inexpensive strainer did a fair job of straining lime pulp, mint, and shards of ice, though because its coils weren’t as narrowly spaced as our winner’s, it wasn’t quite as effective. The coils themselves were a little loose, making the strainer bouncy and harder to control during use. Worse, its top prongs were too short to reach the edges of our larger shaker tin, so it occasionally fell into the shaker while pouring.

Model Number: BST-4P

Handle length: 2.5 in

Distance between coils: 1.3 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $3.98

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

Rabbit Cocktail Strainer

With well-placed prongs, this pretty strainer technically fit into shakers of different sizes. Unfortunately, it was hard to keep it there, as its long, heavy handle upset the balance of the strainer, tipping it backwards if we weren’t holding it in place; worse, there wasn’t even a finger tab to help us maintain our grip on the strainer. As a result, we had to fight to keep the whole shebang pressed against the shaker. Thanks to coils that were fairly far apart, this model was the worst at straining, allowing small masses of lime pulp, mint shreds, and ice shards to pour into our drinks.

Model Number: W9954

Handle length: 4.9 in

Distance between coils: 2.0 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $12.00

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Compatibility

With well-placed prongs, this pretty strainer technically fit into shakers of different sizes. Unfortunately, it was hard to keep it there, as its long, heavy handle upset the balance of the strainer, tipping it backwards if we weren’t holding it in place; worse, there wasn’t even a finger tab to help us maintain our grip on the strainer. As a result, we had to fight to keep the whole shebang pressed against the shaker. Thanks to coils that were fairly far apart, this model was the worst at straining, allowing small masses of lime pulp, mint shreds, and ice shards to pour into our drinks.

Model Number: W9954

Handle length: 4.9 in

Distance between coils: 2.0 mm

Price at Time of Testing: $12.00

*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.

America's Test Kitchen Accolades Badge

Reviews You Can Trust

The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!

The Expert

Author: Miye Bromberg

byMiye Bromberg

Senior Editor, ATK Reviews

Miye is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. She covers bread, booze, and blades.

Miye Bromberg is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. Areas of specialization include bread, booze, and blades. A native of New York, she now lives in Kentucky, where she spends her free time thinking about film, tending her garden, and traveling long distances to eat dosas.

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

This is a members' feature.

America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo