America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

The Best Scrub Brushes

A good scrub brush is indispensable for handling the toughest kitchen messes. We set out to find the best one. 

Editor&aposs Note:Update, December 2024

Our favorite scrub brush by O-Cedar was recently discontinued. We will be updating this review soon with new testing. In the meantime, we recommend our runner-up, the OXO Good Grips Dish Brush.

Top Pick

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

WinnerOXO Good Grips Dish Brush

Testers with smaller hands loved this brush, which has a handle that is 1 inch shorter than our winner’s. Its simple, streamlined design made it pleasant to hold and scrub with from any angle. Its bristles flared out more than most brushes, making it ideal for reaching into corners, and they were clustered far apart, making it easy to rinse food out from between them. One small quibble: Its bristles were a bit softer than those of some of its competitors. It couldn’t always handle the toughest messes as efficiently as our winner, and its bristles bent and frayed slightly after extended use.

Model Number: 21691

Bristle Material: Nylon

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 7 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Testers with smaller hands loved this brush, which has a handle that is 1 inch shorter than our winner’s. Its simple, streamlined design made it pleasant to hold and scrub with from any angle. Its bristles flared out more than most brushes, making it ideal for reaching into corners, and they were clustered far apart, making it easy to rinse food out from between them. One small quibble: Its bristles were a bit softer than those of some of its competitors. It couldn’t always handle the toughest messes as efficiently as our winner, and its bristles bent and frayed slightly after extended use.

Model Number: 21691

Bristle Material: Nylon

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 7 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

What You Need to Know

When tackling the most stubborn messes—whether it’s cooked-on egg, crusty bits of frizzled cheese, or baked-on tomato sauce—we often bypass a sponge entirely and reach for a scrub brush. Scrub brushes offer a few advantages to sponges: Their bristles are better at cutting through tough messes and are less likely to cling to food, their handles help provide good leverage, and they tend to keep our hands out of the mess. But not all scrub brushes are built the same, so we decided to test nine models, made from both natural and synthetic materials, with varying handle lengths and head sizes. They ranged in price from about $5 to about $24. Keeping water temperature, soap amount, and cooked-on foods consistent, we put the brushes through the wringer, powering through messes in skillets (both stainless steel and cast iron) and metal baking pans. We also scrubbed metal bowls covered in sticky biscuit dough and washed each brush upwards of 10 times, either by hand or in the dishwasher. Additionally, we sent copies home with nine editors and test cooks and asked for their feedback after a few weeks of real-world use. We were looking for a brush that could cut through difficult messes, fit comfortably in our hands, rinse clean without hassle, and hold up to all that rigorous scrubbing and cleaning. 

We scrambled eggs in stainless-steel skillets, intentionally creating a stubborn, stuck-on mess to test the brushes' scrubbing power.

It’s All In The Bristles

A good scrub brush is only as reliable as its bristles, and we discovered a few bristle qualities that made scrubbing more effective. First: stiffness. There was a spectrum of bristle stiffness, from soft and flexible to ultrastiff and rigid, and most testers preferred the latter. We found that the brushes with stiffer bristles more effectively cut through tough, burnt-on food remnants, leaving behind sparkling cookware. The brushes with softer bristles—including the one brush with natural-fiber bristles—were unable to scrape up cooked-on messes as efficiently as their stiff-bristled counterparts and instead tended to just smear food around. When used to scrub cast-iron pans crusted with rendered burger fat and metal baking pans sticky with burnt-on tomato paste, mustard, and molasses, softer bristles bent out of shape. This made for unkempt, frayed brush heads whose performance worsened over time. The brush with natural-fiber bristles became the most disheveled.

Bristles that flared outward from the brush heads' sides fit into narrow corners and covered more surface area than non-flared bristles.

The bristles’ arrangement and positioning on the brush heads also mattered. We preferred bristles that flared out from the heads considerably, especially on the sides, reaching beyond the brushes’ hard plastic heads. Widely flared bristles increased the scrubbing surface area, allowing us to scrub off more food with fewer passes. Flared bristles were also more effective at reaching into corners. The heads of brushes with straight, unflared bristles too often knocked into skillet edges or baking pan corners without reaching into them, keeping us from tackling every single stain.

Widely-spaced bristle clusters clung to less debris and rinsed clean without issue. Tightly clustered bristles trapped globs of biscuit dough and crumbs and took longer to rinse clean.

The bristle clusters of some brush heads are packed tightly together, whereas some are spaced far apart. Widely spaced bristle clusters tended to perform best. Crumbs, dough, and other food remnants were less likely to get stuck between these bristle clusters, and if they did, they came loose with a single rinse. Brushes with no gaps between their bristle clusters more easily trapped food, and it took additional rinses under the faucet, cycles in the dishwasher, or even whacks on the sink edge to relinquish the debris. All in all, brushes with stiff, widely flared, well-spaced clusters of bristles prevailed.

Some brushes sported scrapers made of solid plastic meant to power through cooked-on messes, but two models had extra sets of ultrastiff bristles that scrubbed and scraped more effectively.

A Note On Scrapers

In addition to their primary sets of bristles, seven of the nine brushes had extra features intended for the toughest scrubbing challenges. Five brushes had plastic scrapers on their backs, but their designs varied. Testers preferred wide, flat scrapers over narrower, tapered scrapers. In lieu of scrapers, two brushes had strips of short, ultrastiff bristles on their backs. The bristles’ many tips were more abrasive than the solid scrapers, allowing them to more effectively scour away tough burnt-on messes. 

Handles Were Important

The best scrub brush handles assure a comfortable grip and create good leverage. In our testing, one important factor was the angle at which the handle met the brush head. The handles of the most successful brushes in our lineup were gently sloped or curved away from their heads, creating enough space to keep testers’ hands free of mess while maintaining good leverage for scrubbing. The handles of three brushes bent away sharply from their heads at angles that measured more than 45 degrees, which raised our elbows and forced our hands away from the action, making for awkward scrubbing positions. The head of one brush was adjustable, swiveling between a 0-degree angle and a 45-degree angle from its handle, which was intended to increase versatility and scrubbing options. Frustratingly, the lock mechanism wasn’t strong enough to keep the brush head in place, so it flipped back and forth with every stroke and made the brush almost impossible to use. We preferred rigid handles that sloped up at angles of about 45 degrees or less, which positioned our hands close to the brushes.

Handle material and design mattered as well. The best handles were made of  silicone-coated plastic and had built-in ridges or bumps that made for secure, slip-free grips, even when they were wet and soapy. However, silicone didn’t always reign supreme; one silicone-coated handle was hard and supersmooth, causing our hands to slide around in the soapy water and occasionally slip off the brush. The metal handle of one brush and the wooden handles of two others were smooth and pleasant to hold when dry, but slippery when wet, especially during vigorous scrubbing. Only one wooden-handle model was sufficiently rough-textured and easy to grip, but it felt so thin and spindly that stronger testers feared they might snap it in half. Also, the wooden-handled brushes weren’t dishwasher-safe, rendering them more likely to retain stains, odors, food bits, and globs of dough.

Finally, handle length greatly impacted scrubbing ability and comfort. Testers’ preferences generally came down to the sizes of their hands. Those with smaller hands mostly preferred shorter handles  and found longer-handled brushes awkward and uncomfortable to use. Testers with larger hands often recommended brushes with longer handles, complaining about feeling cramped by short handles.

The Best Scrub Brush: O Cedar Rinse Fresh Pot & Pan Brush

One scrub brush, the O-Cedar Rinse Fresh Pot & Pan Brush, easily washed away its competition. Its main set of stiff plastic bristles cut through every mess we threw at it. We liked that the bristles, especially those around the head’s perimeter, flared out and scraped up stains in otherwise inaccessible corners. Wide gaps between bristle clusters ensured that all crumbs, dough, and other remnants rinsed free easily. An extra strip of ultrastiff bristles on its back side powered through challenging burnt-on patches.  The handle was gently curved and easy to maneuver most of the time, and its silicone grip was comfortable and secure even in slippery, soapy water, though its handle was a touch long for some users. It’s also dishwasher-safe and did not become stained during our tests. This brush has earned a permanent place beside our sinks, and we think it deserves a similar spot in your kitchen.

  • Stiff, flared plastic bristles
  • Bristles are arranged in clusters with wide spaces between them
  • Extra strip of ultrastiff bristles on back of head for scraping
  • Gently curved, angled handle
  • Comfortable, easy-to-grip silicone-coated handle
  • Dishwasher-safe

  • Test nine scrub brushes (eight with plastic bristles, one with natural bristles), ranging in price from about $5 to about $24
  • Scramble eggs in a stainless-steel skillet with no oil, then scrub the skillet
  • Bake a mixture of yellow mustard, tomato paste, and molasses in a metal baking pan, then scrub the pan
  • Sear burgers in a cast-iron skillet, then scrub the skillet
  • Smear a metal mixing bowl with Cat Head Biscuit dough, then scrub the bowl
  • Wash the brushes after each test and then 10 additional times by hand or in the dishwasher, according to manufacturer directions
  • Have nine testers use the scrub brushes at home for at least three weeks and provide feedback
01:46

America's Test KitchenScrub BrushesWatch Now

Everything We Tested

Good 3 Stars out of 3.
Fair 2 Stars out of 3.
Poor 1 Star out of 3.

Recommended

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

WinnerOXO Good Grips Dish Brush

Testers with smaller hands loved this brush, which has a handle that is 1 inch shorter than our winner’s. Its simple, streamlined design made it pleasant to hold and scrub with from any angle. Its bristles flared out more than most brushes, making it ideal for reaching into corners, and they were clustered far apart, making it easy to rinse food out from between them. One small quibble: Its bristles were a bit softer than those of some of its competitors. It couldn’t always handle the toughest messes as efficiently as our winner, and its bristles bent and frayed slightly after extended use.

Model Number: 21691

Bristle Material: Nylon

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 7 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Testers with smaller hands loved this brush, which has a handle that is 1 inch shorter than our winner’s. Its simple, streamlined design made it pleasant to hold and scrub with from any angle. Its bristles flared out more than most brushes, making it ideal for reaching into corners, and they were clustered far apart, making it easy to rinse food out from between them. One small quibble: Its bristles were a bit softer than those of some of its competitors. It couldn’t always handle the toughest messes as efficiently as our winner, and its bristles bent and frayed slightly after extended use.

Model Number: 21691

Bristle Material: Nylon

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 7 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Quickie Dish Brush with Microban

This brush’s long, stiff bristles handled every mess, speedily scrubbing through stubborn stains and cooked-on patches. It has a strip of extra-long bristles on the front of its head, which were great for scraping into corners and other hard-to-reach areas. Its wide scraper made short work of burnt eggs and burger bits, and its silicone handle felt good in hand. The only downside: The brush’s extra-long handle juts out from its head at an almost 90-degree angle, which made it uncomfortable for some testers, though it would benefit taller users. 

Model Number: 121MB

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 9 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $9.26

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s long, stiff bristles handled every mess, speedily scrubbing through stubborn stains and cooked-on patches. It has a strip of extra-long bristles on the front of its head, which were great for scraping into corners and other hard-to-reach areas. Its wide scraper made short work of burnt eggs and burger bits, and its silicone handle felt good in hand. The only downside: The brush’s extra-long handle juts out from its head at an almost 90-degree angle, which made it uncomfortable for some testers, though it would benefit taller users. 

Model Number: 121MB

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 9 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $9.26

Recommended with reservations

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Evriholder Bamboo Naturals Dish Scrub Brush

This brush had the stiffest bristles among the wooden-handled brushes, and their advantage was clear: It successfully removed most stains with ease. Its wooden handle was smooth and comfortable but sometimes got slippery. Although the brush’s plastic scraper worked well, it started to wear down after only a few intense scraping sessions. And its bristles had very little space between them, making cleaning difficult—especially since the brush wasn’t dishwasher-safe.

Model Number: BNKSB12-AMZ

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 6.5 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $7.24

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush had the stiffest bristles among the wooden-handled brushes, and their advantage was clear: It successfully removed most stains with ease. Its wooden handle was smooth and comfortable but sometimes got slippery. Although the brush’s plastic scraper worked well, it started to wear down after only a few intense scraping sessions. And its bristles had very little space between them, making cleaning difficult—especially since the brush wasn’t dishwasher-safe.

Model Number: BNKSB12-AMZ

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 6.5 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $7.24

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Rösle Antibacterial Dish Brush

This brush’s stiff bristles scrubbed up difficult messes most of the time, albeit with a bit more effort than some of its competitors. But its cold, stainless-steel handle grew slippery with added soap and water. The brush’s bristles were spaced far enough apart for them to rinse clean easily, but its tiny scraper wasn’t a real match for tough, burnt-on bits, and its skinny, steeply angled handle jutted out awkwardly from its head, sometimes making scrubbing uncomfortable.

Model Number: 12808

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Stainless-steel

Handle Length: 7.25 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $23.94

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s stiff bristles scrubbed up difficult messes most of the time, albeit with a bit more effort than some of its competitors. But its cold, stainless-steel handle grew slippery with added soap and water. The brush’s bristles were spaced far enough apart for them to rinse clean easily, but its tiny scraper wasn’t a real match for tough, burnt-on bits, and its skinny, steeply angled handle jutted out awkwardly from its head, sometimes making scrubbing uncomfortable.

Model Number: 12808

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Stainless-steel

Handle Length: 7.25 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $23.94

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Redecker Tampico Fiber Dish Brush with Untreated Beechwood Handle, 9-Inches

This brush’s tampico fibers—the only natural bristles in our lineup—created a promising lather of suds that was enough to remove some stains, but they bent under forceful pressure and couldn’t always cut through the most stubborn messes. After being used to scrub up burnt-on sauce and bits of rendered burger fat, the bristles were notably crushed and splayed. And while some testers used the edge of its wooden head as an effective scraper and liked its textured wooden handle, others found it spindly and feared it would snap with intense use.

Model Number: 322540

Bristle Material: Tampico fiber

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 6 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $11.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s tampico fibers—the only natural bristles in our lineup—created a promising lather of suds that was enough to remove some stains, but they bent under forceful pressure and couldn’t always cut through the most stubborn messes. After being used to scrub up burnt-on sauce and bits of rendered burger fat, the bristles were notably crushed and splayed. And while some testers used the edge of its wooden head as an effective scraper and liked its textured wooden handle, others found it spindly and feared it would snap with intense use.

Model Number: 322540

Bristle Material: Tampico fiber

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 6 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $11.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Libman Big Job Kitchen Brush

This brush’s stiff bristles did a good job with most messes, but failed to remove the toughest bits of burnt-on sauce and eggs. Its silicone-swathed handle was comfortable to grip but a bit long for some testers, making for awkward scrubbing angles and tired wrists. Some of the bristles got slightly bent out of shape by the time our testing was over, and they were placed so close together that dough sank into their depths and was impossible to extract.

Model Number: 1042

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 8 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $12.11 for set of 2 ($6.05 per brush)

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s stiff bristles did a good job with most messes, but failed to remove the toughest bits of burnt-on sauce and eggs. Its silicone-swathed handle was comfortable to grip but a bit long for some testers, making for awkward scrubbing angles and tired wrists. Some of the bristles got slightly bent out of shape by the time our testing was over, and they were placed so close together that dough sank into their depths and was impossible to extract.

Model Number: 1042

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 8 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $12.11 for set of 2 ($6.05 per brush)

Not Recommended

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Full Circle Be Good Kitchen Dish Brush with Bamboo Handle

This brush’s bristles were too soft to tackle tough messes, and they were arranged so close together that crumbs, dough, and other detritus got lodged in their midst with every scrubbing session and wouldn’t rinse out. The brush’s wooden handle was slippery, and the plastic scraper on its back did little to scrape up cooked-on mess. It also was not very durable: The brush’s head began to separate from its handle halfway through our tests. 

Model Number: FC10108

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 5.5 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s bristles were too soft to tackle tough messes, and they were arranged so close together that crumbs, dough, and other detritus got lodged in their midst with every scrubbing session and wouldn’t rinse out. The brush’s wooden handle was slippery, and the plastic scraper on its back did little to scrape up cooked-on mess. It also was not very durable: The brush’s head began to separate from its handle halfway through our tests. 

Model Number: FC10108

Bristle Material: Recycled plastic

Handle Materials: Wood

Handle Length: 5.5 in

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $5.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

Casabella Swivel Dish Brush

This brush’s head, designed to swivel 45 degrees and present multiple scrubbing angles, was poorly designed. It repeatedly swiveled back and forth as we scrubbed, providing neither the stability nor the leverage necessary to effectively scrub. Its awkward handle, among the longest in the lineup, had a silicone grip, but it was still quite slippery in soapy water. Its soft bristles couldn’t handle even moderate burnt-on messes.

Model Number: 5540029

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 9 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $13.99 for set of 2 ($6.99 per brush)

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush’s head, designed to swivel 45 degrees and present multiple scrubbing angles, was poorly designed. It repeatedly swiveled back and forth as we scrubbed, providing neither the stability nor the leverage necessary to effectively scrub. Its awkward handle, among the longest in the lineup, had a silicone grip, but it was still quite slippery in soapy water. Its soft bristles couldn’t handle even moderate burnt-on messes.

Model Number: 5540029

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 9 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $13.99 for set of 2 ($6.99 per brush)

Discontinued

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

O-Cedar Rinse Fresh Pot & Pan Brush

This brush aced every category with ease: No stain could withstand its stiff bristles, it rinsed clean with minimal effort thanks to its well-spaced bristle clusters, its silicone-coated handle was comfortable to grip, and its handle curved optimally to give it good leverage for scrubbing. It also had a strip of ultrastiff bristles on the back of its head meant for the toughest messes that beat out every scraper in the lineup. Though its handle was a touch long for some testers, this brush easily outperformed its competition.

Model Number: 041785997840

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 8 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.99

  • Performance
  • Ease of Use
  • Cleanup
  • Durability

This brush aced every category with ease: No stain could withstand its stiff bristles, it rinsed clean with minimal effort thanks to its well-spaced bristle clusters, its silicone-coated handle was comfortable to grip, and its handle curved optimally to give it good leverage for scrubbing. It also had a strip of ultrastiff bristles on the back of its head meant for the toughest messes that beat out every scraper in the lineup. Though its handle was a touch long for some testers, this brush easily outperformed its competition.

Model Number: 041785997840

Bristle Material: Plastic

Handle Materials: Plastic, silicone

Handle Length: 8 in

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.99

*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.

America's Test Kitchen Accolades Badge

Reviews You Can Trust

The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!

The Expert

Author: Chase Brightwell

byChase Brightwell

Associate Editor, ATK Reviews

Chase is an associate editor for ATK Reviews. He's an epidemiologist-turned-equipment tester and biscuit enthusiast. 

Chase Brightwell is an associate editor for ATK Reviews. He left a career in infectious disease research to answer fascinating food questions full-time. He loves combining his culinary passions with analytical methods to evaluate equipment and ingredients—from grill gloves, fire pits, and cleaning supplies to heirloom beans and puff pastry. He lives in Maine with his husband, daughter, and black lab and has never met a biscuit he didn't like.

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

This is a members' feature.

America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo