America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

Salt Storage Containers

Salt containers placed near the stove make it easy to season a steak or a pot of boiling water on the fly. We put five to the test.

What You Need to Know

Salt containers placed near the stove make it easy to season a steak or a pot of boiling water on the fly. There are two basic kinds: Salt pigs are open-mouthed cylindrical vessels, while salt boxes have lids and tend to be slightly smaller. Wondering if there was a trade-off between the access of an open container and the protection of a lidded one, we tested both kinds—two salt pigs and three boxes, ranging in price from about $10.00 to $40.00. We wanted a container that would be sturdy, hold a useful amount of salt, be easy to fill and access, and protect the salt from kitchen splatter and from clumping in humid conditions. And if we were going to get a dedicated salt container, it had to do all of these things better than a simple prep bowl, so we tested our containers alongside a 6-ounce glass bowl.

Not surprisingly, the lidded salt boxes did a superior job of protecting their salt from messes. When we left each container next to a skillet of simmering tomato sauce, only the salt boxes kept the salt pristine and splatter-free. Some splatter made it into the salt pigs, but it was less than the mess that landed in the ordinary open bowl.

To see how well the containers protected their salt against humidity, we filled them with kosher salt and placed them in a warm, damp room for a weekend. As we expected, the salt in the open bowl and in the pigs had clumped, forming nearly solid masses that were hard to dig out. The salt in the lidded boxes fared better; while small clumps still formed, they were easy enough to break up with a spoon.

After giving the containers to several test cooks to try, we realized that access to the salt pigs was actually more limited than with the lidded containers. Despite their wide mouths, the salt pigs were harder to fill and use. The Emile Henry salt pig’s curve and the Le Creuset crock’s flat top and shallow retaining wall limited their capacities and forced us to tilt the vessels to fill them with salt, which was awkward and still resulted in some spillage. The same features also made it awkward for large-handed testers to reach into the bottom of the vessels when the salt was running low and for testers of all hand sizes to measure and level off a teaspoon of salt. By contrast, the salt boxes were effortless to load and access from above and turned out to be easy to open with one hand.

If you want an attractive vessel that will protect your salt against splatters and humidity (if only to a limited extent), a salt box is a nice option. Our favorite, the Bee House Salt Box, holds 2 cups of salt; solid and roomy, it sat sturdily on the counter, required infrequent refilling, and did a better job of accommodating cooks with large hands. Our Best Buy, the Totally Bamboo Round Salt Box, holds just ¾ cup of salt but costs less than half the price of the winner; while its light weight made it easier to knock off the counter by accident, some testers preferred its more compact size and secure magnet closure.

Everything We Tested

Good 3 Stars out of 3.
Fair 2 Stars out of 3.
Poor 1 Star out of 3.

Recommended

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

WinnerBee House Salt Box

This sturdy flip-top salt box held plenty of salt and provided easy access to it, accommodating most testers’ hands. While somewhat vulnerable to humidity, this box was great at shielding salt from messes. It was a breeze to fill and clean and could be opened with one hand; a small handle made it convenient to lift for on-the-fly seasoning.

Model Number: BCB-01

Cover: Yes

Weight: 16.4 oz

Capacity: 2 cups

Material: Stoneware, hinoki (Japanese cypress), stainless steel

Dimensions: 6.5 x 3.375 x 3.5 in

Price at Time of Testing: $20.80

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

This sturdy flip-top salt box held plenty of salt and provided easy access to it, accommodating most testers’ hands. While somewhat vulnerable to humidity, this box was great at shielding salt from messes. It was a breeze to fill and clean and could be opened with one hand; a small handle made it convenient to lift for on-the-fly seasoning.

Model Number: BCB-01

Cover: Yes

Weight: 16.4 oz

Capacity: 2 cups

Material: Stoneware, hinoki (Japanese cypress), stainless steel

Dimensions: 6.5 x 3.375 x 3.5 in

Price at Time of Testing: $20.80

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

Best BuyTotally Bamboo Round Salt Box

With a lid that fastened with a magnet, this salt box—the least expensive in our lineup—was easy to open, fill, and use. It kept out moisture and messes about as well as our winner. Our only gripes? It didn’t hold a lot of salt, so it needed more frequent refilling, and it was lightweight, making it easy to knock off the counter.

Model Number: 20-2083

Cover: Yes

Weight: 4.8 oz

Capacity: ¾ cup

Material: Bamboo, neodymium iron boron magnet with nickel plating

Dimensions: Cylinder; 3.5-in diameter, 3-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $8.99

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

With a lid that fastened with a magnet, this salt box—the least expensive in our lineup—was easy to open, fill, and use. It kept out moisture and messes about as well as our winner. Our only gripes? It didn’t hold a lot of salt, so it needed more frequent refilling, and it was lightweight, making it easy to knock off the counter.

Model Number: 20-2083

Cover: Yes

Weight: 4.8 oz

Capacity: ¾ cup

Material: Bamboo, neodymium iron boron magnet with nickel plating

Dimensions: Cylinder; 3.5-in diameter, 3-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $8.99

Recommended with reservations

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

RSVP Endurance Salt Server with Spoon

This utilitarian flip-top salt container was easy to fill and use, decent at protecting against humidity, and great at protecting against splatters. But with several removable glass, metal, and silicone parts, it was precarious to lift as a unit. A tiny serving spoon was cute but ultimately not all that useful, dispensing less than ⅛ teaspoon of salt.

Model Number: ALTN

Cover: Yes

Weight: 13.3 oz

Capacity: ¾ cup

Material: Glass, stainless steel, silicone

Dimensions: Cylinder; 4.5-in diameter, 3-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $20.38

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

This utilitarian flip-top salt container was easy to fill and use, decent at protecting against humidity, and great at protecting against splatters. But with several removable glass, metal, and silicone parts, it was precarious to lift as a unit. A tiny serving spoon was cute but ultimately not all that useful, dispensing less than ⅛ teaspoon of salt.

Model Number: ALTN

Cover: Yes

Weight: 13.3 oz

Capacity: ¾ cup

Material: Glass, stainless steel, silicone

Dimensions: Cylinder; 4.5-in diameter, 3-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $20.38

Not Recommended

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

Emile Henry Salt Pig

Sturdy and large, this salt pig looked promising. But its shape made it tricky to fill and awkward to use; the pig also failed to protect the salt from direct tomato sauce splatters (it did, however, best the open bowl in this test, and you could turn the opening away for further protection). Worse, its unglazed clay interior drank in moisture, creating the most extensive salt clumping seen in this testing.

Model Number: 850201

Cover: No

Weight: 16.6 oz

Capacity: 1 ¾ cup

Material: Burgundy clay

Dimensions: Bent cylinder; 4-in diameter, 5-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $37.99

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

Sturdy and large, this salt pig looked promising. But its shape made it tricky to fill and awkward to use; the pig also failed to protect the salt from direct tomato sauce splatters (it did, however, best the open bowl in this test, and you could turn the opening away for further protection). Worse, its unglazed clay interior drank in moisture, creating the most extensive salt clumping seen in this testing.

Model Number: 850201

Cover: No

Weight: 16.6 oz

Capacity: 1 ¾ cup

Material: Burgundy clay

Dimensions: Bent cylinder; 4-in diameter, 5-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $37.99

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

Le Creuset Salt Crock

A shallow bottom rim limited the actual capacity of this large, expensive salt pig; the whole thing had to be laid on its side to be filled. Its flat top made access uncomfortable for large-handed testers. It provided no protection against moisture and only limited protection from direct splatter (although, again, it was better than a prep bowl, and splatter protection could be increased by turning the opening away from the stove).

Model Number: PG1020-1059

Cover: No

Weight: 18.4 oz

Capacity: 1 ½ cups

Material: Stoneware

Dimensions: Cylinder; 5-in diameter, 5-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $34.95

  • Stability
  • Ease of Use
  • Ease of Filling
  • Mess Protection
  • Humidity Protection

A shallow bottom rim limited the actual capacity of this large, expensive salt pig; the whole thing had to be laid on its side to be filled. Its flat top made access uncomfortable for large-handed testers. It provided no protection against moisture and only limited protection from direct splatter (although, again, it was better than a prep bowl, and splatter protection could be increased by turning the opening away from the stove).

Model Number: PG1020-1059

Cover: No

Weight: 18.4 oz

Capacity: 1 ½ cups

Material: Stoneware

Dimensions: Cylinder; 5-in diameter, 5-in height

Price at Time of Testing: $34.95

*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.

America's Test Kitchen Accolades Badge

Reviews You Can Trust

The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

This is a members' feature.

America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo