America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

The Best Syrup/Honey Dispensers

What’s the best tool to control a sticky situation?

Top Pick

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

WinnerAmerican Metalcraft Beehive Syrup Dispenser, 6 oz.

This dispenser’s spring-loaded spout cover worked like a charm. Pushing the lever let us open it any amount from a sliver to fully open, so we could pour neatly and precisely while controlling the flow. Releasing the lever let it slide smoothly and shut completely for no-drip handling. It was easy to fill and clean, too. One quibble: The glass jar isn’t microwave-safe, so we had to heat syrup in a separate vessel and then transfer it. On the plus side, the ridged glass jar stayed comfortable to hold as we replaced the lid, even when the syrup was fairly hot.

Model Number: BSD64

Capacity: 6 oz

Materials: Glass and metal

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.80

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

This dispenser’s spring-loaded spout cover worked like a charm. Pushing the lever let us open it any amount from a sliver to fully open, so we could pour neatly and precisely while controlling the flow. Releasing the lever let it slide smoothly and shut completely for no-drip handling. It was easy to fill and clean, too. One quibble: The glass jar isn’t microwave-safe, so we had to heat syrup in a separate vessel and then transfer it. On the plus side, the ridged glass jar stayed comfortable to hold as we replaced the lid, even when the syrup was fairly hot.

Model Number: BSD64

Capacity: 6 oz

Materials: Glass and metal

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.80

What You Need to Know

Maple syrup and honey can make for sticky fingers, tables, and counters—and if you add kids to the mix, that list can easily grow to include furniture, pets, and houseguests. Maple syrup dispensers promise to neaten up the task of pouring the sticky stuff. Typically designed as a small pitcher with a covered spout operated by a lever, a syrup dispenser should be easy to fill and clean and should pour a controlled amount without undue dripping. We bought five dispensers, with capacities between 6 and 19 ounces and made from glass or plastic. Four were pitcher-style; the fifth dispensed from the bottom of the container. We put each one through its paces with warm, cold, and room-temperature syrup, pouring it over both real pancakes and pancake-size circles drawn on paper to assess how easy it would be to control the output and hit a precise target. We enlisted both right- and left-handed testers of varying strengths and sizes to find the dispenser that worked best for the most people.

Testing was an eye-opener. A few dispensers gushed and splashed beyond our paper patterns, and one drowned our pancakes under a tsunami of syrup. “If I had children and this was our syrup dispenser, we would not be having pancakes,” one tester declared. A few models had closures that were too loose—they never fully cut off the flow—or designs that forced the flow of syrup back over the lid, making a mess. The best models had comfortable handles, closed fully after dispensing, and had just the right amount of tension in the trigger to let us pour as much or as little as we wanted without hand strain. But two models gave us perfect control, whether we wanted a trickle or a hefty pour, with almost no dripping.

tester pouring syrup from a dispenser onto pancakes
Pouring syrup from a dispenser shouldn’t be a challenge, but we found several of the models we tested very challenging indeed.

Of the two models that topped our performance tests, one—the bottom-flowing dispenser—may have been a dream to operate, but it was a nightmare to fill: When you remove the top of this hollow glass ball-shaped vessel, it also removes an attached stem that plugs the bottom hole, leaving it open at both ends. So you must balance the vessel upright while pressing the bottom hole flat to a surface as you pour in order to keep syrup in. Once it’s full, you keep the dispenser in that position while screwing on a springy lid that tries to pop up and whose large, curved handle bumps into your other hand each time you twist. Not fun. Another strike: This model can’t go in the dishwasher, unlike the rest of the lineup.

pouring maple syrup from a bottom-pouring dispenser onto pancakes
One dispenser set itself apart with its unique bottom-pouring construction that was easy to control, but we later discovered that the design isn’t without its flaws.

That led us to our winner, whose simple design, pouring control, and overall ease of use won the day. The American Metalcraft Beehive Syrup Dispenser holds 6 ounces of syrup or honey and deploys a flat metal sliding cover that closes snugly over the spout, letting you dispense only the syrup you need, exactly where you want it. Its metal top screws off easily to make refilling and cleaning straightforward and simple, and it emerged from our dishwashing tests intact. Its only downside: The manufacturer says the glass container should not be microwaved, so we had to heat syrup in a separate container. But the dispenser’s ribbed surface stayed cool as we screwed the lid onto the warm pitcher. (As an alternative, we could put the filled dispenser in a bowl of hot water to gently warm the contents.) Best of all, it was the cheapest model in our lineup. Next time we serve pancakes, we’ll be pouring syrup from our new winner.

  • Fill and check capacity
  • Dispense room-temperature, 145-degree, and 40-degree maple syrup onto circles on paper and onto pancakes to assess control and flow of syrup
  • Heat syrup to 145 degrees in containers where possible, or heat in measuring cup and fill dispenser with warm syrup
  • Pour room-temperature liquid honey from each dispenser to assess control and flow of honey
  • Have right- and left-handed testers of varying skill and size pour room-temperature maple syrup onto paper circles
  • Wash by hand or in dishwasher (as indicated by manufacturer) at least 10 times and check for damage or warping
  • Open and close lid lever 25 times to test durability

  • Snug-closing spout cover that allows control of flow and precise pouring
  • No drips
  • Comfortable handle and lever
  • Easy to fill and clean
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Sturdy and durable construction
00:54

America's Test KitchenSyrup DispensersWatch Now

Everything We Tested

Good 3 Stars out of 3.
Fair 2 Stars out of 3.
Poor 1 Star out of 3.

Recommended

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

WinnerAmerican Metalcraft Beehive Syrup Dispenser, 6 oz.

This dispenser’s spring-loaded spout cover worked like a charm. Pushing the lever let us open it any amount from a sliver to fully open, so we could pour neatly and precisely while controlling the flow. Releasing the lever let it slide smoothly and shut completely for no-drip handling. It was easy to fill and clean, too. One quibble: The glass jar isn’t microwave-safe, so we had to heat syrup in a separate vessel and then transfer it. On the plus side, the ridged glass jar stayed comfortable to hold as we replaced the lid, even when the syrup was fairly hot.

Model Number: BSD64

Capacity: 6 oz

Materials: Glass and metal

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.80

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

This dispenser’s spring-loaded spout cover worked like a charm. Pushing the lever let us open it any amount from a sliver to fully open, so we could pour neatly and precisely while controlling the flow. Releasing the lever let it slide smoothly and shut completely for no-drip handling. It was easy to fill and clean, too. One quibble: The glass jar isn’t microwave-safe, so we had to heat syrup in a separate vessel and then transfer it. On the plus side, the ridged glass jar stayed comfortable to hold as we replaced the lid, even when the syrup was fairly hot.

Model Number: BSD64

Capacity: 6 oz

Materials: Glass and metal

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $7.80

Recommended with reservations

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

WMF Kult Honey/Syrup Dispenser

This pricey dispenser has a spring-loaded spout cover that opens smoothly. Too bad it doesn’t actually work to control the flow of syrup: It was either fully open or closed, and the rate of the flow was up to your pouring arm, not the dispenser. The results? Initially messy pouring and a steep and sticky learning curve. And if the cover wasn’t fully open, the syrup would flow back onto the lid, causing drips and mess. Attractive and solidly built, with a wide opening for filling and cleaning, this is basically a covered pitcher.

Model Number: 06.3664.6040

Capacity: 8 oz

Materials: Glass and stainless steel

Microwave-Safe: Glass container only

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $42.00

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

This pricey dispenser has a spring-loaded spout cover that opens smoothly. Too bad it doesn’t actually work to control the flow of syrup: It was either fully open or closed, and the rate of the flow was up to your pouring arm, not the dispenser. The results? Initially messy pouring and a steep and sticky learning curve. And if the cover wasn’t fully open, the syrup would flow back onto the lid, causing drips and mess. Attractive and solidly built, with a wide opening for filling and cleaning, this is basically a covered pitcher.

Model Number: 06.3664.6040

Capacity: 8 oz

Materials: Glass and stainless steel

Microwave-Safe: Glass container only

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $42.00

Not Recommended

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

Norpro Honey/Syrup Dispenser

Unlike the other models, this attractive vessel dispenses syrup from the bottom of the container, which sits in a glass base that can be filled with warm water to help keep honey or syrup soft and flowing. It works beautifully, dispensing neatly and precisely—until it’s time to refill, an awkward, messy process that one disappointed tester called “a real deal breaker.” The chrome-painted plastic lid and dispensing plug felt flimsy and cheap, and the dispenser can’t go in the microwave or dishwasher.

Model Number: 780

Capacity: 8 oz

Materials: Glass and plastic

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $18.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

Unlike the other models, this attractive vessel dispenses syrup from the bottom of the container, which sits in a glass base that can be filled with warm water to help keep honey or syrup soft and flowing. It works beautifully, dispensing neatly and precisely—until it’s time to refill, an awkward, messy process that one disappointed tester called “a real deal breaker.” The chrome-painted plastic lid and dispensing plug felt flimsy and cheap, and the dispenser can’t go in the microwave or dishwasher.

Model Number: 780

Capacity: 8 oz

Materials: Glass and plastic

Microwave-Safe: No

Dishwasher-Safe: No

Price at Time of Testing: $18.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

Trudeau Syrup Dispenser

This dispenser has no metal parts, so you can pop the whole thing into the microwave, and its thick plastic walls held heat for a long time. We liked its large capacity, too. But the flimsy plastic spout cover never closed properly, and testers were surprised by how much syrup unexpectedly gushed out, drenching pancakes and splashing outside our paper circles with abandon. Unless you are a big fan of Jackson Pollock, pass this one by.

Model Number: 998990

Capacity: 19 oz

Materials: Polypropylene and styrene acrylonirile (plastic)

Microwave-Safe: Yes

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $11.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

This dispenser has no metal parts, so you can pop the whole thing into the microwave, and its thick plastic walls held heat for a long time. We liked its large capacity, too. But the flimsy plastic spout cover never closed properly, and testers were surprised by how much syrup unexpectedly gushed out, drenching pancakes and splashing outside our paper circles with abandon. Unless you are a big fan of Jackson Pollock, pass this one by.

Model Number: 998990

Capacity: 19 oz

Materials: Polypropylene and styrene acrylonirile (plastic)

Microwave-Safe: Yes

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $11.99

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

Paderno World Cuisine Syrup Dispenser

With a too-tight spring-loaded lever and a sharp-edged handle, this dispenser was uncomfortable for most testers and offered no help with control, since its spout cover had only two positions—fully open or closed. When we did try to use it to limit flow, some syrup flowed back onto the lid, making a sticky, drippy mess. The small spout opening meant that thicker honey emerged at a maddening trickle. You can put the glass portion in the microwave, but the thinness of the glass made the jar too hot to handle, and potholders slipped off its tapered shape as we tried to screw on the lid. The lid itself felt lightweight, and threading it onto the jar usually took a few tries.

Model Number: 41525-00

Capacity: 10 oz

Materials: Glass and stainless steel

Microwave-Safe: Bottom glass portion only

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $19.95

  • Ease of Use
  • Performance
  • Cleanup / Durability

With a too-tight spring-loaded lever and a sharp-edged handle, this dispenser was uncomfortable for most testers and offered no help with control, since its spout cover had only two positions—fully open or closed. When we did try to use it to limit flow, some syrup flowed back onto the lid, making a sticky, drippy mess. The small spout opening meant that thicker honey emerged at a maddening trickle. You can put the glass portion in the microwave, but the thinness of the glass made the jar too hot to handle, and potholders slipped off its tapered shape as we tried to screw on the lid. The lid itself felt lightweight, and threading it onto the jar usually took a few tries.

Model Number: 41525-00

Capacity: 10 oz

Materials: Glass and stainless steel

Microwave-Safe: Bottom glass portion only

Dishwasher-Safe: Yes

Price at Time of Testing: $19.95

*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.

America's Test Kitchen Accolades Badge

Reviews You Can Trust

The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!

The Expert

Author: Lisa McManus

byLisa McManus

Executive Editor, ATK Reviews

Lisa is an executive editor for ATK Reviews, cohost of Gear Heads on YouTube, and gadget expert on TV's America's Test Kitchen.

Lisa McManus is an executive editor for ATK Reviews, cohost of Gear Heads on YouTube, host of Cook's Illustrated's Equipment Review videos, and a cast member—the gadget expert—on TV's America's Test Kitchen. A passionate home cook, sometime waitress, and longtime journalist, she graduated from Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism and worked at magazines and newspapers in New York and California before returning like a homing pigeon to New England. In 2006 she got her dream job at ATK reviewing kitchen equipment and ingredients and has been pretty thrilled about it ever since. Her favorite thing is to go somewhere new and find something good to eat.

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

This is a members' feature.

America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo