America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

The Best Pastry Brushes

Finding the best pastry brush is a delicate business.

Editor&aposs Note:UpdateJanuary 2019

Recently, we learned that our winning pastry brush, Winco Flat Pastry and Basting Brush, 1½ inch, contains BPA, a chemical that some studies link to various health issues. For those who are concerned about BPA, we recommend our runner-up, Ateco 1.5" Flat Stainless Steel Ferrule Pastry Brush, which is BPA-free.

Top Pick

  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

WinnerWinco Flat Pastry and Basting Brush, 1½ Inch

This brush had the thickest head of bristles in the testing, allowing it to pick up and deposit the greatest volume of egg wash, oil, butter, or glaze in a single pass. And because the bristles weren't too densely packed, they still felt agile and precise. At a uniform 1.8 inches, they were the ideal length for most tasks (though some testers preferred brushes with slightly longer bristles for getting into the nooks and crannies on fruit tarts). While not as grippy as some, its medium-length, relatively fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. Additionally, it lost the fewest bristles during testing.
Model Number: WBR-15Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 2Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.8 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.93
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
This brush had the thickest head of bristles in the testing, allowing it to pick up and deposit the greatest volume of egg wash, oil, butter, or glaze in a single pass. And because the bristles weren't too densely packed, they still felt agile and precise. At a uniform 1.8 inches, they were the ideal length for most tasks (though some testers preferred brushes with slightly longer bristles for getting into the nooks and crannies on fruit tarts). While not as grippy as some, its medium-length, relatively fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. Additionally, it lost the fewest bristles during testing.
Model Number: WBR-15Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 2Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.8 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.93

What You Need to Know

We love our favorite silicone brush for basting meat and poultry and for oiling hot pans. But for spreading egg wash, glaze, or melted butter on delicate doughs or pastry and for removing crumbs from layer cakes before frosting them, we prefer to use a pastry brush with natural-fiber bristles. Because these bristles are so fine, they allow you to apply liquids more precisely and with a gentler touch than silicone models, which generally have thicker, spaghetti-size bristles. Moreover, natural-fiber brushes simply have more bristles, so they can wick up more liquid.

We wanted to know which natural-fiber pastry brush was the best, so we bought six models and pitted them against our reigning silicone model, the OXO Good Grips Silicone Pastry Brush. All the brushes had 1.5-inch-wide heads (the most commonly available size); five were made with boar’s-hair bristles and one with silk bristles. We put them to the test, using them to apply viscous egg wash to raw bread dough, slick olive oil to sheets of phyllo, and thick, sticky glazes to fruit tarts.

Tester brushing egg wash on bread dough, brushing oil on phyllo dough, and adding glaze to a fresh fruit tart with a pastry brush
We evaluated the brushes on how well they performed in delicate applications such as spreading egg wash on bread dough, brushing oil on phyllo dough, and adding glaze to a fresh fruit tart.

Bristles Determine Minor Performance Differences

The good news is that all the brushes did a respectable job with every task. Compared with our favorite silicone model, the natural-fiber brushes picked up two to four times more liquid and dispensed it much more evenly, gently, and precisely.

However, there were some minor differences in performance that were determined by the length, uniformity, and density of the bristles; the material itself didn’t seem to be significant. Bristles that were just under 2 inches in length provided the right combination of agility and coverage. Longer bristles were great for reaching into the nooks and crannies of the fruit tarts but were a touch unwieldy when applying oil to phyllo. Shorter bristles felt stubby and had less surface area with which to cover the food; they lacked the supple swish and fluidity of longer bristles.

Most testers also preferred brushes with bristles that were uniformly the same length throughout the head; bristles of different lengths tended to stick out like flyaways, making for slightly less precise, controlled application.

Additionally, we liked brush heads that were moderately dense, about ½ inch or more in thickness. The thicker the brush head, the more bristles it generally had and thus the more liquid it could retain, letting us reload the brush a little less often. Still, these differences in capacity weren’t all that dramatic—at most, it meant that a brush took three passes to cover a 14 by 9-inch sheet of phyllo instead of two.

And while we wanted a thick head with lots of bristles, it was important that the bristles not be too tightly bunched inside the head. Brushes with densely packed bristles felt stiff and were a little rougher on the food, pushing over and bruising some of the berries on the fruit tart and more readily tearing the phyllo dough.

Five lined-up pastry brushes comparing the length of their bristles
Not all natural-fiber pastry brushes are alike; factors including bristle length, density, and evenness all affect overall performance.

Handles Matter

Handle shape and material mattered as well. We liked handles that were comfortable to hold for extended sessions, preferring those that were relatively thick (2 to 2.5 inches in circumference) and made from materials that were easy to grip even when wet or greasy; rubbery plastic was ideal, but varnished wood was just fine, too. Bare metal was too slippery, and unfinished wood made testers worry about splinters. Handles of medium length (4.75 to 5 inches) were easy for testers of all hand sizes to wield precisely; longer handles took us a little too far from the action and generally made for clumsier maneuvering.

Four pastry brushes lined up comparing their handles
Testers of all hand sizes found the medium-length finished-wood handle of our winning brush comfortable.

A Durability Problem

Finally, a note about durability. Natural-fiber pastry brushes are somewhat notorious for shedding bristles when you use and wash them. The brushes in our lineup were no exception: They each dropped at least a couple of bristles over the course of testing, and the worst lost more than a dozen, not including any that may have been shed during dish washing.

Close-up of a glazed fresh fruit tart
Although natural-fiber brushes can shed fibers onto food, cooks prize them for their superior performance in delicate, precise tasks.

Our winner, the Winco Flat Pastry and Basting Brush, 1½ inch, was the most durable of the bunch, losing just two bristles during testing and handwashing. Those bristles were uniformly the ideal length for most testers (1.8 inches) and there were plenty of them, packed neither too tightly nor too loosely into the brush head, which was the thickest in our lineup. As a result, the brush picked up some of the greatest volumes of liquid, but it still felt flexible, maneuverable, and precise. Finally, its thick, varnished wood handle was easy for testers of all hand sizes to hold.

The Tests

  • Apply egg wash to raw bread dough
  • Apply glaze to fruit tart
  • Apply olive oil to sheets of phyllo dough
  • Wash each brush by hand 10 times
  • Record bristles lost throughout testing
  • Have users of different hand sizes, dominant hands, and levels of pastry experience test-drive


How We Rated

  • Performance: We evaluated each brush on how much liquid it held and how agile, precise, and gentle it was in action.
  • Comfort: We rated each brush on how grippy and comfortable it was to hold.
  • Durability: We evaluated each brush on how durable it was, counting the number of bristles it lost over the course of testing.

  • Bristles that are uniformly 1.8 to 1.9 inches long
  • Moderately dense bristle head that measures about ½ inch thick
  • Grippy handle 4.75 to 5 inches long and 2 to 2.5 inches in circumference
  • Loses relatively few bristles during use and handwashing
04:49

America's Test KitchenPastry and Silicone BrushesWatch Now

Everything We Tested

Good 3 Stars out of 3.
Fair 2 Stars out of 3.
Poor 1 Star out of 3.

Recommended

  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

WinnerWinco Flat Pastry and Basting Brush, 1½ Inch

This brush had the thickest head of bristles in the testing, allowing it to pick up and deposit the greatest volume of egg wash, oil, butter, or glaze in a single pass. And because the bristles weren't too densely packed, they still felt agile and precise. At a uniform 1.8 inches, they were the ideal length for most tasks (though some testers preferred brushes with slightly longer bristles for getting into the nooks and crannies on fruit tarts). While not as grippy as some, its medium-length, relatively fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. Additionally, it lost the fewest bristles during testing.
Model Number: WBR-15Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 2Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.8 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.93
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
This brush had the thickest head of bristles in the testing, allowing it to pick up and deposit the greatest volume of egg wash, oil, butter, or glaze in a single pass. And because the bristles weren't too densely packed, they still felt agile and precise. At a uniform 1.8 inches, they were the ideal length for most tasks (though some testers preferred brushes with slightly longer bristles for getting into the nooks and crannies on fruit tarts). While not as grippy as some, its medium-length, relatively fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. Additionally, it lost the fewest bristles during testing.
Model Number: WBR-15Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 2Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.8 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.6 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.93
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

Ateco 1.5" Flat Stainless Steel Ferrule Pastry Brush

With a thick head of uniformly sized bristles that were just a tad longer than our winner's, this model picked up plenty of liquid and was relatively agile. Although we slightly preferred rubbery handles, its fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. The problem? It lost 14 bristles over the course of testing, leaving some doubt as to its longevity.
Model Number: 60015Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 14Handle length: 5 inBristle length: 2 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.5 inPrice at Time of Testing: $10.99
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
With a thick head of uniformly sized bristles that were just a tad longer than our winner's, this model picked up plenty of liquid and was relatively agile. Although we slightly preferred rubbery handles, its fat, varnished wood handle was still comfortable to hold. The problem? It lost 14 bristles over the course of testing, leaving some doubt as to its longevity.
Model Number: 60015Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, varnished wood handleBristles lost: 14Handle length: 5 inBristle length: 2 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 2 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.5 inPrice at Time of Testing: $10.99
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

OXO Good Grips 1.5" Pastry Brush

This pastry brush did a good job on all the tasks, though its wispy bristles didn't pick up quite as much liquid and were a touch harder to control due to their inconsistent length. Testers loved the grippy, rubbery material of the handle, though its shape forced them to choke up on the thinnest part near the head, limiting the number of ways they could hold the brush and cramping their hands a little.
Model Number: 73881Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, plastic handleBristles lost: 4Handle length: 6 inBristle length: 1.9 in (varies)Dishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.3 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.99
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
This pastry brush did a good job on all the tasks, though its wispy bristles didn't pick up quite as much liquid and were a touch harder to control due to their inconsistent length. Testers loved the grippy, rubbery material of the handle, though its shape forced them to choke up on the thinnest part near the head, limiting the number of ways they could hold the brush and cramping their hands a little.
Model Number: 73881Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, plastic handleBristles lost: 4Handle length: 6 inBristle length: 1.9 in (varies)Dishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2.5 inBristle head thickness: 0.3 inPrice at Time of Testing: $6.99
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

Norpro 1½-inch Pastry Brush

The bristles on this petite, paintbrush-like model were shorter, thinner, and less uniform in length than our top choices, picking up slightly less liquid and feeling less precise and controllable as a result. It shed seven bristles over the course of testing, and its rough, unfinished wood handle had testers worrying about splinters. Still, this brush acquitted itself well on all tasks, and it was the cheapest model to boot.
Model Number: 2015Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, unvarnished wood handleBristles lost: 7Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.5 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2 inBristle head thickness: 0.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $5.32
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
The bristles on this petite, paintbrush-like model were shorter, thinner, and less uniform in length than our top choices, picking up slightly less liquid and feeling less precise and controllable as a result. It shed seven bristles over the course of testing, and its rough, unfinished wood handle had testers worrying about splinters. Still, this brush acquitted itself well on all tasks, and it was the cheapest model to boot.
Model Number: 2015Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, unvarnished wood handleBristles lost: 7Handle length: 4.75 inBristle length: 1.5 inDishwasher-safe: NoHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2 inBristle head thickness: 0.4 inPrice at Time of Testing: $5.32

Recommended with reservations

  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

Matfer Bourgeat Flat Pastry Brush

With a thin head of extra-long, wispy bristles, this model excelled at applying glaze to the nooks and crannies of the fruit tart. But for most tasks, both the long bristles and the long handle felt a bit oversize, “like using a paint stirrer instead of a paintbrush,” as one tester put it. The manufacturers of this model recommended soaking the head in water for an hour before the first use to reduce bristle loss, but even after we'd taken this precaution, it shed eight bristles during testing.
Model Number: 116014Materials: Boar's hair bristles, plastic handleBristles lost: 8Handle length: 6.75 inBristle length: 2.2 inDishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2 inBristle head thickness: 0.25 inPrice at Time of Testing: $10.00
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
With a thin head of extra-long, wispy bristles, this model excelled at applying glaze to the nooks and crannies of the fruit tart. But for most tasks, both the long bristles and the long handle felt a bit oversize, “like using a paint stirrer instead of a paintbrush,” as one tester put it. The manufacturers of this model recommended soaking the head in water for an hour before the first use to reduce bristle loss, but even after we'd taken this precaution, it shed eight bristles during testing.
Model Number: 116014Materials: Boar's hair bristles, plastic handleBristles lost: 8Handle length: 6.75 inBristle length: 2.2 inDishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.5 to 2 inBristle head thickness: 0.25 inPrice at Time of Testing: $10.00
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance

Rösle Pastry Brush

With a thin wire loop for a handle and a short, dense shock of bristles, this pastry brush was aesthetically pleasing but not always a great performer. Those tightly packed bristles were fine for brushing egg wash onto a loaf of bread but were a bit too rough on delicate raspberries and sheets of phyllo. Testers found its handle awkward and uncomfortable to hold for longer sessions, and it shed a fair number of bristles over the course of testing.
Model Number: 124685Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, stainless-steel handleBristles lost: 8Handle length: 6.25 inBristle length: 1.3 inDishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.3 inBristle head thickness: 0.25 inPrice at Time of Testing: $15.95
  • Comfort
  • Durability
  • Performance
With a thin wire loop for a handle and a short, dense shock of bristles, this pastry brush was aesthetically pleasing but not always a great performer. Those tightly packed bristles were fine for brushing egg wash onto a loaf of bread but were a bit too rough on delicate raspberries and sheets of phyllo. Testers found its handle awkward and uncomfortable to hold for longer sessions, and it shed a fair number of bristles over the course of testing.
Model Number: 124685Materials: Boar's-hair bristles, stainless-steel handleBristles lost: 8Handle length: 6.25 inBristle length: 1.3 inDishwasher-safe: YesHandle circumference: 1.3 inBristle head thickness: 0.25 inPrice at Time of Testing: $15.95

*All products reviewed by America’s Test Kitchen are independently chosen, researched, and reviewed by our editors. We buy products for testing at retail locations and do not accept unsolicited samples for testing. We list suggested sources for recommended products as a convenience to our readers but do not endorse specific retailers. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices are subject to change.

America's Test Kitchen Accolades Badge

Reviews You Can Trust

The mission of America’s Test Kitchen Reviews is to find the best equipment and ingredients for the home cook through rigorous, hands-on testing. We stand behind our winners so much that we even put our seal of approval on them. Have a question or suggestion? Send us an email at atkreviews@americastestkitchen.com. We appreciate your feedback!

The Expert

Author: Miye Bromberg

byMiye Bromberg

Senior Editor, ATK Reviews

Miye is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. She covers bread, booze, and blades.

Miye Bromberg is a senior editor for ATK Reviews. Areas of specialization include bread, booze, and blades. A native of New York, she now lives in Kentucky, where she spends her free time thinking about film, tending her garden, and traveling long distances to eat dosas.

Reviews You Can Trust.
See Why.

This is a members' feature.

America's Test Kitchen LogoCook's Country LogoCook's Illustrated Logo